Simon Ward reviews Seagull at the Hen and Chickens Theatre
Director Julia Stubbs, together with cast members Lisa Minichiello and Emma Riches, have adapted Anton Chekhov’s The Seagull to create a version that runs straight through in 100 minutes. It is an impressive feat, and they seem to me to have retained the essence of the piece. What is not so clear, however, is the director’s vision of the play. Notoriously, Chekhov thought himself to be writing comedies, no matter how they might be performed or received by audiences. Certainly in this production there are elements where his intent seems to be overtly satirical, and at other points he seems to be sending up the self-indulgent misery of his characters. But, although this seemed to be the case in the writing, it did not always come through in the performance. Consequently the show sometimes seemed to arrive in a no-man’s-land where it did not know whether we were meant to laugh or cry. Perhaps this is an ambiguity that Stubbs would be happy to live with and the power of Chekhov’s writing does shine through. But, for me, more confidence and clarity about what the play actually is would have made it more satisfying.
The set seems to be a rehearsal room, with the floors and walls festooned with annotated pages of script and an impromptu stage set up for the play-within-a-play. This is not followed through however – there is no setup where we understand this to be a rehearsal, it just seems to be a minimalist set. We can, however, rely on Chekhov’s descriptive language to conjure up the luxurious mansion set beside a beautiful lake.
The nine-strong all-female cast consist of Cici Clarke (Arkadina), Grace Bown (Nina), Emma Riches (Konstantin), Lisa Minichiello (Trigorin), Leonor Lemée (Polina), Mary Tillett (Sorin), Jessamy James (Masha), Astrid Olofsson (Medvedenko) and Patrizia Petrassi (Dorn). Cici Clarke shines in the role of the monstrous Arkadina, a narcisstic actress who has never found the time to read a single thing written by her son Konstantin. He, in turn, is desperately and disastrously in unrequited love with Nina, a young aspiring actress, who only has eyes for Arkadina’s lover, successful middle-ranking and middle-aged novelist Trigorin. This company assembles in the country residence of the ailing Sorin, Arkadina’s brother. Polina, as wife of the steward, takes care of the running of the house, while her daughter Masha miserably mopes around, despite being wooed by poor but well-intentioned schoolteacher Medvedenko. Family friend and retired doctor Dorn completes the household.
As their loves and squabbles play out, Chekhov makes fun of their intense self-involvement, and their utter indifference to the innumerable working people whose labour enables their lives of luxuriant idleness. It is very telling that when the climactic tragedy strikes, the most pressing concern of all involved is how to manage it as decorously as possible, while making the minimum of fuss. An interesting production, which could profitably dare to be even bolder in its interpretation.
Seagull is running at the Hen and Chickens Theatre, 109 Saint Paul’s Rd, London N1 2NA until Saturday 28th November



Explore All Our Reviews